In Dallas County, a 22-year old male can purchase a $5,000 deductible (hospitalization only) major medical policy for $384 per year from Blue Cross of Texas. That would be more than enough for most recent college grads. Yet, the CBO estimates the average premium for the second-lowest cost “silver” plan for an individual in 2016 is $5,000. It appears to me that Obama will hike the cost of insuring young people by $4,615. That equals $9,232 per young couple just out of college!
Of course, the cost differential in Devon’s example is not for equal coverage. The $384 was for hospitalization-only coverage, and the $5,000 is for comprehensive coverage that the individual will be forced to buy.
Risk adjustment for catastrophic coverage is one thing; I have a harder time forcing one person to pay for another’s out-of-pocket costs.
Too bad the only choices have been a rather extreme progressive package, a slightly less extreme libertarian proposal which goes in the opposite direction, and the status quo.
As a “dictionary conservative” I’d like to see incremental change, quite possible in a libertarian direction, but much more cautious than what has been proposed. This seems to put me right in the middle of the three existing options, none of which I find palatable. “Circular firing squad” seems the wrong analogy; perhaps “scorpion surrounded by a circle of fire” comes closer.
Published twice per week, Health Alerts are exclusive, in-depth analyses of health care policy by John Goodman. Subscribe via RSS or enter your email address in the box above.
Didn’t the President say he would lower costs for the average family by $2,500?
In Dallas County, a 22-year old male can purchase a $5,000 deductible (hospitalization only) major medical policy for $384 per year from Blue Cross of Texas. That would be more than enough for most recent college grads. Yet, the CBO estimates the average premium for the second-lowest cost “silver” plan for an individual in 2016 is $5,000. It appears to me that Obama will hike the cost of insuring young people by $4,615. That equals $9,232 per young couple just out of college!
Of course, the cost differential in Devon’s example is not for equal coverage. The $384 was for hospitalization-only coverage, and the $5,000 is for comprehensive coverage that the individual will be forced to buy.
Risk adjustment for catastrophic coverage is one thing; I have a harder time forcing one person to pay for another’s out-of-pocket costs.
Too bad the only choices have been a rather extreme progressive package, a slightly less extreme libertarian proposal which goes in the opposite direction, and the status quo.
As a “dictionary conservative” I’d like to see incremental change, quite possible in a libertarian direction, but much more cautious than what has been proposed. This seems to put me right in the middle of the three existing options, none of which I find palatable. “Circular firing squad” seems the wrong analogy; perhaps “scorpion surrounded by a circle of fire” comes closer.
I don’t see any cost curve getting bent here.